Saturday 2 November 2019

It's complicated: Where our ancestors came from

Introduction and summary

The area in Botswana today -
definitely not fertile
In "Origin of modern humans 'traced to Botswana'," researchers claim to have determined where we modern humans first evolved in Africa 200,000 years ago before spreading to the rest of Africa and then to the rest of the world starting around 130,000 years ago. They argue that analyses of the distribution in modern Africa of a type of DNA passed only from mothers to children shows that the original home of our species was an area in modern Botswana, which would then have been very fertile, unlike the barren salt pan area it is today. However, other scientists remain unsure that the DNA analyses is enough to support this claim about our complex evolution.

____________________________________ 

Response: What is your opinion?

Modern science continually amazes me. Today, we know more about our origins than any other humans in history have ever known, and unlike the stories told by religions, the creation stories of physics, chemistry, biology and other sciences are solidly founded on verifiable facts and sound reasoning. I had already known that Mitochondrial Eve, the last common female ancestor of every human being alive today, lived around 150,000 years ago, and I had already been amazed that anthropoligists had been able to narrow the area down to Africa after decades of careful work. If we look at other sciences, we now know more about the universe around us, including that it's almost 14 billion years old, than anyone would have imagined possible when I was born last century, and the rate of new discoveries keeps accelerating, as my ever smarter smart phones demonstrate. What might we know tomorrow?

But as I read and thought about the article, I was also reminded how the mathematical tools used to recreate evolutionary histories from modern DNA can be applied in very different areas. Last term in one of my classes we read an article about how these statitical analyses can be used to trace fairy tales back through evolving human languages for thousands of years as groups split like species do to create new languages and new cultures, a process that is still going on in every living language and the culture it encodes. 

In fact, if I had to pick just one scientific discovery, I might choose Darwin's theory of evolution, which he published in 1859, as the most important ever. Evolution is not so deep as the theories of modern physics, or so Earth shattering as the Copernican revolution that moved us humans from the centre of the universe, but by connecting us to every other living thing through the mindless operation of perfectly blind natural processes, it showed us our place in nature and finally helped us get over the need for stories of gods and other supernatural things to explain the living wonder of the world we inhabit. 


____________________________________ 

Question for your classmates

Why do scientists and others want to understand where we humans began?  

2 comments:

  1. Although I had not written my response, I decided to post it as another example as soon as I had finished my summary. As usual, my first draft of the summary was too long, but only a little. It was 122 words. The current summary in my words, after the usual five or six revisions, is 116 words which is safely within the 120 word limit.


    I've also written a new title. The first titles we wrote in class were temporary. It's usual to give your work a title after it's finished because that's when you know what it finally says. I might change mine again, and I still have to write the response here first.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And as usual, my response, which is 350 words here, tool much less time to write than the summary.

      Delete

Before you click the blue "Publish" button for your first comment on a post, check ✔ the "Notify me" box. You want to know when your classmates contribute to a discussion you have joined.

A thoughtful response should normally mean writing for five to ten minutes. After you state your main idea, some details, explanation, examples or other follow up will help your readers.

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.