Wednesday, 29 April 2009

How one country (mis)treats the mentally ill

I'm sure that there are other countries that are as bad or even worse, but "Locking up Nigeria's 'civil lunatics' ", which I just saw on the BBC News website, is pretty shocking. The report details, with facts and examples, how Nigeria treats its mentally ill. Basically, it throws them into prison and forgets them. 
I was trying to think what was the worst thing about this story: the misery of the people locked up for no good reason or their neglect by society and their own families. In the end I decided that the worst thing was that this was all perfectly legal, that "colonial-era law allows Nigerian courts to jail the mentally ill" (¶ 6)! As is too often the case, a country's laws are the enemy of justice for the citizens. 
__________
References
Locking up Nigeria's 'civil lunatics'. (2009, April 29). BBC News. Retrieved April 29, 2009 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8023067.stm 

Daniel's question: Is Quest wrong?

In his comments this morning, I thought that Daniel raised an important question: that books are often wrong, that they sometimes contain ideas or statments which are false, or even worse. 
My question, which you might like to leave a comment on, is why is this such a very important point to raise? Why is it so important that I let you spend 20 minutes discussing Daniel's question this morning? 

Also important, though less so, is the specific question of whether or not Quest is wrong in this case. Does Hartmann say something wrong in "Culture and Mental Illness" (2007)? Please also feel welcome to share your ideas on this narrower question. 
__________
References
Hartmann, P. (2007). Quest 2 Reading and Writing (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill ESL/ELT


Tuesday, 28 April 2009

How Japanese consider mental illness

Generally, in Japan, we tend to ignore mental illnesses in normal lives because traditional people consider that complaining mental illnesses come from weakness of mental then it could be ashamed. Therefore, we would seek psychologists only when we feel something wrong physically, for example we can’t sleep or eat for several days but there is no evidence of physical illness. However, if behavior of ones’ friend or relative becomes abnormal, he or she would recommend them to see psychologists. Then we would take care of them as mentally challenged, such as avoiding having conversation which make them too much concerned, or accepting their abnormal behavior.

Michiyo on mental disease

Some young people who suffer from anorexia nervosa or bulimi ask the psychologists to help in my culture. Some people who suffer from depression also do that. Actually we don't know how to deal with abnormal behavior in a friend or relative, so we have better not to act by personal perspective. I mean it is not that we ignore them. We should respond according to psycholosists or doctor' direction. The prescriptions are various and complicated depends on the patients.

abnormal behavior in thai aspect

Talking about abnormal behavior, in my country, Thailand, it’s not usual to go to see doctors when you’ve a little bit fever or some small problems with your health. Most of Thai people would like to keep their money to pay with pressure things” gold, electrical appliances, new version of mobile, etc.” and let nature deal with those kinds of problem. For that reason, they’ll seek for psychologists help when it is necessary situation “uncontrolled or harmful” because, they always think that everyone who goes to see psychologists is an insane person. On the other hand, when they have to deal with friend or relative who has abnormal behavior, they will talk care them as usual and keep them relax.

Culture and Mental illness by -[DeE-Di]-

In my culture,most of the people have never thought to seek the help of psychologists. Althought,they've a lot of problems in their life.They always solve the problems by themselves which can make them to be an abnormal behavior.They can't know that ,they're being an abnormal behavior by themselves until friend or relative will tell them or may be they can't know forever because they've already crazy.The people who have mental diseases must be looked after closely by thier relative or friend such as take a sick person to travel,try to tell a funny story etc. Don't keep them to be alone because they will harm themselves.The best way is take them to seek the help of psychologists.Moreover,friend or relative of the patient must look after themselves too otherwise they will be an abnormal behavior soon.

Have you ever seen psychologist ?

In Thai culture, people seek the help of psychologists when their relatives or their friends or monks can not help them.Moreover, many patients do not go to a psychiatric hospital because other people may think they are crazy and "Crazy People" is the worst symbolic that they receive from society. I think most people deal with abnormal behavior in a friend or relative by observing behavior of who have problems and then if behavior is not severe and does not disturb others, they help the patient by themselves or go to the temple to ask monk to treat. But if abnormal people have severe symptom, they will be persuaded to see psychologist. In addition, there are not enough psychologists and psychiatric hospitals in Thailand.

Seeking help of psychologist

In my culture, peoples do not want to see the psychologist because they believe that the persons who go to seek the help of psychologist are an abnormal person or have a serious mental illness. Therefore, peoples will go to see the psychologist when they think they cannot control or handle with their problem such as they cannot stop thinking that there is a person who wants to kill them or they are in danger all the time. Moreover, when they think those things can cause an anxiety feeling, an abnormal behavior or mental illness, which is impact on their lifestyle. For this reason, they will go to see the psychologist.

People should understand the abnormal behavior in friend or relative and try to help them. Do not ignore them. Try to listening to their problem and give them empathy. Besides, people should always support you friend or relative who have a problem and deal with them with the positive feeling.

Pang on psychological disorder

In Thai culture, only people who have a severe mental illness seek the help of psychologists. Normally, most Thais think that all patients who treat by psychologists are crazy. The patients do not want to be looked down by society, so they try to cheat themselves that they are normal and avoid to see psychologists. However, they need someone to take care and listen their problems closely. Friend is a person that they trust and want to tell anything. When people know that their friend has a mental illness, they should not tell him directly. It is probably makes the symptom worse. They should tell his parents and suggest taking him to see psychologists that is the best to treat his psychological disorder.

Psychologist in Thai Culture

Usually Thai people who have mental problems didn’t go to see the psychologist because they think that psychologist or psychiatrist treat only abnormal people and they don’t want to be a mental disorder patient. However, they will go to see the psychologist when their abnormal behaviors are more disturb their routine life. For example, they are more depressed and couldn’t work. Moreover, the abnormal behaviors person need more help and support from their friends and family more than going to see the psychologist.

An on abnormal disorder

In my culture, there are not many people seek the help of psychology. Those who seek the help could not sleep, or they have a strange dream. For the abnormal people, they are not usually taken to the hospital for that kind of people. They stay at home and their family take care of them. For the rich family, they take care that person very carefully and they have a special doctor for that person. For the poor family, they just let that person in his way, that why some of them always dirty and they don't stay at home. In my country we don't discriminate them, we just need to be careful with them, because they can't control themself sometimes.

PommePomme on psychological disorder

To seek the help of psychologists is not popular in my country. Somes are scared that when anyone know that they met the doctor they will look like they are crazy! but somes aren't care about this because they are not crazy but they are stressful. They want some good listeners to listen to their problems and make them calm down. They will feel more comfortable after they met psychologist. No one can lives without friends so friends are important to deal with these abnormal behavior friends to don't make it worse. To deal with them we can try to speaking with our abnormal friends about their abnormal behavior that you can feel. If your abnormal friend is in basic step he/she can improve him/herself, it will be good but if it doesn't work try to advise him/her to meet the psychologist. Don't make your abnormal friend worried about it.
__________

May on psychological disorder

The psychologists have important role to first help people who have psychological disorder and sort the patients to cure. If they can not treat the doctors in this field will treat them. In my culture, the psychologists are not important role. General people don't know the exactly duty that the psychologists do. High level education of people know what they do and they seek the help from them when they have some problems and some symtoms such as insomnia, stress. Perhaps general people may think that they do not want everyone know their disorder, so they do not use the psychologists service.

Mental illness

Mental illness does not discriminate between genders, socioeconomic status, age or race; everyone can have a mental illness. Some research has indicated that genes possibly play a role in the development mental illnesses. In general, people in Thai culture have mental illness; they will get suggestions from close friends or their own family. They will try and find out if there are any underlying problems together. If a solution after consulting with close friends and family can’t be found, the person who may be mentally challenged will be advised to consult with psychologists or psychiatrists for professional treatment of their symptoms. The psychologist will treat patient in different methods depending on the patient’s symptoms. For the best one method to treat patient is inform the patient family how to take care of them. In short, if you see someone exhibiting abnormal behavior or mental illness, you should encourage them and treat them like a normal person.

Thursday, 9 April 2009

Peter on Art

I don't much like most of the art in chapter 3 of Quest 2, but one piece that I do like is Les Très Riches Heures du duc de Berry, Février, by the Limbourg brothers. This painting is on page 85 of Quest, where it looks a bit drab and colourless. I actually checked Google image search and found a much better copy of it online. In fact, I found colour images of most of the pieces of art used in chapter 3 of Quest 2, and I've put them all online.
The first thing I liked about Les Très Riches Heures du duc de Berry, Février, is that it shows a lot of detail of the people's daily life. There are people working outdoors and others relaxing indoors. There are also a lot of details that can tell us about their lives: the sort of work they did, their daily activities, what they ate, and so on. Other details tell us a lot about the place, which is a snowy country in Europe. There is a church in the background, so the people and place in the foreground are not alone. There must be other people around to go to the church. We can even get a lot of information about the clothes the people wore, and their social customs. Apparently, it was OK to pull up your clothes in front of a warm fire! In the larger and more colourful image online, I was surprised to see the details of the man in the middle with pulled up clothes.
Another thing I like are the wonderful colours, especially the very rich blue at the top of the paining.

Pang on Art

The pieces of art thai I am interested is The Death of general Wolf, by Benjamin West (American). The picture show war history. I would like to know what happen there. I think all of them from western but There is the only one who look like native people. At first I think the war is between native people and western people. When I look it again, it maybe not. A native people can sit with other western people and no one angry on him. The thing that I learn from this picture is war bring only disaster. When war is started, some people will die certainly.

Da on Art

You favorite peice of art from any culture.
my favorite piece of art is Cooling Off by the Riverbank, by Kitakawa Utamaro [Janpan].Late 18th century.when I look at this picture I like culture in japan especailly culture about lifestye and wearing cloths.I like women in janpan who wear cloth polite and lovely.The culture about wearing cloth of janpan looks like Korea but in japan has nany culors and beautiful culors.The culture in japan ,agroup of people look

May on Art

A picture in Quest 2 on page 72, This picture is a man who standing and carrying the bowl. This picture is strange because it is not look like general human. His body is round and has tiny arms and has not legs. His head is open like a bowl to contain something such as water or flowers. It made of clay by hands and tools. It has some cracks that mean it was broken at one time. From Quest 2 on page 73"In history, this sculpture is about 2600 years old. It burned incense or held a religious offering to a god of the Edomite people. It was broken in the seventh century B.C.E.when King Josiah ordered his soldiers to destroy the culture of "PAGAN" or non-Jewish religions." It is a piece of art in this chapter.

Nana on Art

Topic: anything that interested you in this chapter

In the ominbus, I see two women and one baby in the train. where do they go? I guess they are going to visit in birthplace. It take place 1891 in The UK because they wear British clothes and the capture tell me. The printer tell about culture of community when the people take the train and go to anywhere. The older woman look out of window and think when the train arrive the target station. She watch carfully around her.The younger woman is holding baby and don't interesting around her. She feel funny with trip. The baby wear luxully dressing. She is sitting in the younger woman. She don't sleep and she is quit clam. I guess the trip is long time. The printer draw this picture during jouney in other country. The printer keep about culture and history on her picture.

__________
References
and enter your source reference citations here (If your post doesn't cite any sources, delete this entire section)

An on Art

There is a funeral in the painting, Lamentation from Avignon, France. 1320-1350. Everyone looks very sad in the picture. Some ladies are crying and hugging the dead person. The men are preparing for the funeral. I think they are Christians, because there is a cross at the background. This painting was painted in 1320 to 1350, but the the way people are dressing in the picture I think this case happened nearly the time Jesus Christ was born, maybe before or after but it's not too far. The figure of people in this picture look like the people in Israel, I guess that because when I was young I used to watch the movie about the people in Bible, they are look like.
I'm not interested in art, so when I look at the painting I don't have much feeling.

Lila on Art

When i studying in chapter 3, i really interested in some picture that show about Art religion because it can make me to understand more about religion from other culture and how they believe on their figure. Before i never look carefully of my figure, what they look like? where is the Buddha sitting ? And how we can believe on him ? but when i finished this chapter 3 i can understand my religion, is Buddha is sitting in the intermediary and the largest of other that we can see the the full face. It can make me believe of the Buddha that he always look after what ever we did and bright good luck to us and our family, too. Event in the family, if some one death, we just think of Buddha face then we can think that our relation that is in other world already in them best way.